40 tracked items. 26 still open, 14 settled.
Where two sources disagree, or where a claim rests on a single unverified report, the site carries a visible BEST GUESS ### label at the point of doubt. Each number links here; each entry links back to every page where the claim appears.
Numbers are permanent. A settled item keeps its number rather than being
renumbered, so a screenshot your alliance sent citing BEST GUESS 005 still means
005 a year from now.
How to correct one
Play the game, observe the truth, and post the number plus a screenshot in Discord. That is the whole process. The number is the reference — you do not need to describe which page it came from.
The sources¶
Source A — YouTube guides by the player Pxulxx, captured 14 September 2026. Source B — official developer Discord, captured the same day: announcements, patch notes, all 38 strategy threads, ~6,300 community messages. Source C — official app store listings, added after an external review found Source B's platform data was nine months stale.
Where B is tagged official and A is a player's on-camera description, the site follows B. Where both are player-sourced, the site presents both and labels it.
Open — needs in-game evidence¶
BEST GUESS 002 — World Transfer: leave your alliance, or be in one?¶
A: you must leave your alliance to apply. B: requirements include "belong to an alliance." Mutually exclusive, and the action is irreversible.
Settles it: a screenshot of the transfer requirements panel during a live migration window. Appears on: World Transfer
BEST GUESS 004 — Beast levelling: star 7 or star 3?¶
A: a beast must be star 7 to be levelled. B (patch note, 28 May 2026): the requirement was reduced to 3 stars. A is probably just pre-patch.
Settles it: try to level a 3-star beast. Appears on: Beasts
BEST GUESS 005 — Kills Day shields¶
A: altar fighting does not drop your shield, but entering the central area does — hence "park outside it." B: every player gets a free 24-hour shield on Kills Day as standard design.
If B is right, A's caution is obsolete. If A is right, following B loses troops. This one can cost you an army, so the site states neither as fact.
Settles it: check your shield icon after crossing into the central area. Appears on: Guardian Altar · Events Overview
BEST GUESS 006 — Titan Spine Isle entry requirements¶
Three incompatible figures:
- A (in-game mail): 50 members; 50 logged in within 3 days; 35 with T8 troops
- B (chat screenshot): 30 logged in within 3 days; 15 with T7 — while the screenshot's own counters read "1/30" and "0/25", matching neither
- B elsewhere: minimum Basecamp 6, with alliances free to set higher bars
The most consequential item in the register. An alliance that registers without meeting the real bar loses a 45-day season. The site prints no numbers.
Settles it: one clean screenshot of the registration requirements panel. Appears on: Titan Spine Isle
BEST GUESS 008 — Dragon's Treasure cadence¶
A: every two to three weeks, Saturday reset to Monday reset. B: listed as daily. B's own detail section describes tiers unlocking "next time the event runs", which reads periodic.
Settles it: watch your event tab for two weeks. Appears on: Dragon's Treasure · Events Overview
BEST GUESS 011 — Quanti's tier¶
A: "S tier for sure." B (roster): A — Epic. Likely A is ranking by usefulness and B is recording rarity. The site says "A-rarity, played like an S."
Settles it: his rarity border in the hero list. Appears on: Heroes · Quanti Action
BEST GUESS 014 — Shards from unlock to 5 stars¶
Three figures in B alone: a player table totalling 965 with four confirming reactions; Pxulxx's explicit guess of ~800; a third player's 1000+.
965 is best supported and is what the site uses, but it is not a confirmed constant.
Settles it: record the shard cost at each star step on one hero. Appears on: Heroes · Glossary
BEST GUESS 015 — Ultimate Alliance Duel length¶
A: six days, Monday to Saturday. B: a full week, with Sunday's highest weekly total winning. Both agree Saturday is kills day.
Settles it: does Sunday score points, or only settle? Appears on: Ultimate Alliance Duel
BEST GUESS 016 — Lucky Wheel gem economics¶
A: 500 gems per spin; 30,000 gems left a hero ~50 shards short of maxed. B: "save about 4,000 gems for each wheel to take a copy of each new legendary" — eight spins at A's rate.
Probably answering different questions (unlock vs star-up), but the site does not assume that.
Settles it: shard count from a known gem spend. Appears on: Lucky Wheel
BEST GUESS 017 — Lucky Wheel duration¶
A says two days in one video and three in another. B gives cadence but not duration. Unresolved in both sources.
Settles it: the event timer. Appears on: Lucky Wheel
BEST GUESS 020 — Exclusive gear upgrade material¶
A: "blue stones." B: Energy Prisms. Probably the same item under its proper name, unconfirmed.
Settles it: the item name in the upgrade screen. Appears on: Hero Gear
BEST GUESS 023 — Beast breakthrough materials¶
A: beast meat, fangs, feral energy cores. B (Aug/Sep 2026 rework): Razor Fangs and Resilient Scales were retired and swapped for generic Breakthrough Items. A appears to describe the state between two reworks.
Settles it: the current material names in the beast level screen. Appears on: Beasts
BEST GUESS 024 — First beast hatch time¶
A: ~10 hours. B: ~14 hours. Both community-sourced.
Settles it: time one hatch at a known hatchery level. Appears on: Beasts
BEST GUESS 026 — Troop hospital buildings¶
A: seriously injured go to the clinic (fast); fallen go to the emergency hall (slow), and anything over its capacity is permanently lost. B's building list: a Med Bay for sick residents and a Hospital for wounded soldiers — no emergency hall at all.
The permanent-loss rule matters and B does not corroborate it.
Settles it: the building list in your outpost after a heavy defeat. Appears on: Economy · Glossary
BEST GUESS 029 — Stamina sources¶
A: two free loads daily plus one from Bach. B: the Bar refill refreshes at 00:00 and 12:00, 12 hours each. Possibly the same thing described differently; Bach's third load is A-only.
Settles it: count your free stamina in one day. Appears on: Daily Events · Free-to-Play
BEST GUESS 030 — Build order¶
Two experienced players disagree. "Level everything": keep all buildings near your Outpost level. "Prioritise": rush Basecamp 30 and raise only barracks, resource buildings, both rally buildings, beast buildings and research.
Not an error — a genuine strategic split. Both are on the site.
Settles it: nothing. This is opinion, kept for transparency. Appears on: Economy · New Player Roadmap
BEST GUESS 031 — R5 inactivity replacement trigger¶
The community manager said 3 consecutive days in December 2025 and 36 hours in March 2026. Internal to B.
Settles it: observe one leader transfer. Appears on: Accounts and Support
BEST GUESS 032 — Customer support hours¶
Support channel: Mon–Fri 01:30–10:00 UTC. Player FAQ: daily 01:30–10:30. Internal to B.
Appears on: Accounts and Support
BEST GUESS 033 — Hall of Fame maximum level¶
"Level 400 is max" stated once, in reply to a question, never corroborated.
Settles it: a screenshot of a high Hall of Fame entry. Appears on: Heroes
BEST GUESS 034 — Server merge interval¶
One source said both "4 or 5 months" and "5 or 6 months" for the first merge.
Appears on: Accounts and Support
BEST GUESS 035 — Titan Spine gameplay detail¶
B flags that much of its Titan gameplay section was extrapolated by a player from equivalent modes in other games. Tower counts (300), camp counts (20) and creature behaviour are provisional. A's material came from in-game mail and is firmer.
Settles it: playing one season. Appears on: Titan Spine Isle
BEST GUESS 036 — Google Play supported devices¶
An external review reports the Google Play listing supports phone, tablet and Chromebook. Not independently verified here — the listing is JavaScript-rendered and could not be fetched.
Apple's side is verified: iPhone, iPad, Mac with M1 or later on macOS 12+ (marked "not verified for macOS"), and Apple Vision.
Settles it: the "Available on" section of the Play listing. Appears on: Accounts and Support
BEST GUESS 037 — Exclusive Gear launch date¶
B (Discord patch timeline): 13 August 2026. External review citing Apple's version history: 20 August 2026, with an Android build dated 14 August carrying the same note.
Store notes routinely lag staged rollouts, so both may be true. The site says "mid-August."
Appears on: Hero Gear
BEST GUESS 038 — Does the Hero Pass free track give shards?¶
A: the free track pays no shards at all for a newly released hero, making that hero a paid unlock in practice. B: free players obtain every S-tier hero "by hoarding gems and spending them in the Hero Pass and Lucky Wheel."
These cannot both be true, and it decides whether the Hero Pass is a free route or a paywall. Found while acting on an external review; catalogued by neither.
Settles it: the free track's contents on the next hero release. Appears on: Free-to-Play · Lucky Wheel
BEST GUESS 039 — Armored Tricera spend threshold¶
One player reported needing at least $300 in the Summer Revelry shop, and $500+ for the beast plus every cosmetic. Official announcements confirm a new orange beast but give no price. Single-source.
Settles it: the event shop's purchase table. Appears on: Beasts · Spending Guide
BEST GUESS 040 — Legendary hero acquisition matrix¶
No official table of how each legendary is obtained has ever been published. The site previously said the Lucky Wheel was the only free route; that is too strong given Bach is in the standard recruitment pool and the trade shop sells golden hero shards.
The full current matrix is unknown, so the site avoids "only" about any route.
Settles it: an official acquisition table, or a systematic community audit. Appears on: Lucky Wheel · Heroes · Free-to-Play
Settled — no longer flagged on the site¶
These were contradictions. They are resolved, the losing claim has been removed from the guides, and the numbers are retained so old references still resolve.
001 — Fire Fiend is not a rally, and you get 5 attacks per day in total, not 5 per spawn. Settled by B's dedicated guide. A's "send a rally" was wrong.
003 — You cannot aid a gold beast with another gold beast. Settled by two players from experience in B, explicitly correcting the answer A repeated.
007 — Cross-world teleport on Kills Day consumes no relocation items. Settled by B.
009 — Corvus and Akali are Shooters, not Riders. Settled by B's published roster.
010 — Faction sizes are 8 Warrior / 10 Shooter / 6 Rider, not 8/8/8. Settled by the same roster.
012 — Hermione is a research hero, not a PvP hero. B states this as a direct correction of third-party videos.
013 — "Noah" and "Noel" are one hero, spelled Noel. Internal to B, self-flagged.
018 — Hunting Festival sandwiches come from diamonds, speed-ups, wild monsters, gathering, sub-modes and packs — not just daily tasks and the puzzle. A was incomplete rather than wrong.
019 — Orange gear comes from the Arena shop (one weekly), Lucky Chests at 0.25%, and paid packs. A's "adventure mode" is not an orange source.
021 — Beast Badges come from Entombed Solpolis. A's "Intuned Soulpurus" was a mangled caption of the same name.
022 — The summer beast is the Armored Tricera, per the official announcement. A's "Rock Tricera" was a mishearing. (The $300 price is separate — see BEST GUESS 039.)
025 — The orange beast hatch window is Thursday through Friday, widened from Thursday-only on 3 September 2026. A was pre-patch.
027 — The Resolution Chamber currency is Satisfaction Coins, capped at 2,000,000. B additionally supplied the six resolution names and costs.
028 — Rally Hall and Rally Center had their names swapped on 23 July 2026, functions unchanged. Any guide older than that date uses them inverted.
Corrections applied from external review¶
An external audit in September 2026 found seven statements that were not uncertain but simply wrong, mostly through propagation — this register correctly labelled something uncertain, a guide restated it as fact, and an overview page compressed it into an absolute.
All seven are corrected:
- Platform support — "Google Play and iOS only, no PC client" rested on a December 2025 statement. Apple lists Mac and Apple Vision compatibility.
- Exclusive Gear "introduced with Season 1" — it launched mid-August, before the season, which our own patch timeline already showed.
- "35 open items" — there were 35 tracked, of which 22 were unresolved.
- Titan Spine "66 days over 5 phases" — the page listed six phases summing to 67.5. 66 is the total through end of battle, excluding settlement.
- Core Mining "the only source" of exclusive gear shards — our own gear page said missions were added to the duel and Fortune Mobilization on 27 August.
- "Lucky Wheel is the only free legendary route" — see BEST GUESS 040.
- "Bach is the only legendary obtainable without paying" — he is the only S-tier in the standard recruitment pool, which is a different claim.
The rule adopted to stop this recurring: anything carrying an open BEST GUESS number may not appear anywhere else without its label. Absolutes — only, never, always, every, exactly — and specific prices require an official source or direct in-game evidence.